Front Reading

Front Reading

IF YOU CAN READ THIS THE BITCH FELL OFF BIKER RIDER SLEEVELESS T SHIRT
IF YOU CAN READ THIS THE BITCH FELL OFF BIKER RIDER SLEEVELESS T SHIRT
Paypal   US $16.19
IF YOU CAN READ THIS I THREW THE BITCH OFF BIKER RIDER SLEEVELESS T SHIRT
IF YOU CAN READ THIS I THREW THE BITCH OFF BIKER RIDER SLEEVELESS T SHIRT
Paypal   US $16.19
1 vintage original Dick Jane reading poster front back print cirriculum Puff EC
1 vintage original Dick Jane reading poster front back print cirriculum Puff EC
Paypal   US $27.53
Synthetic Lace Front Wig Read Description
Synthetic Lace Front Wig Read Description
Paypal   US $2.25
1910 barber nicklecirulatedcan read the date clearlynice coin front and back
1910 barber nicklecirulatedcan read the date clearlynice coin front and back
Paypal   US $4.99
MACBOOK AIR 13 LCD BACK COVER FRONT BEZEL HINGES 661 5732 LATE 2010 AS IS READ
MACBOOK AIR 13 LCD BACK COVER FRONT BEZEL HINGES 661 5732 LATE 2010 AS IS READ
Paypal   US $114.39
OEM AUDI A3 FRONT DOME LIGHT READING LIGHT 2006 2010
OEM AUDI A3 FRONT DOME LIGHT READING LIGHT 2006 2010
Paypal   US $45.99
MOROSO DRAG SPECIAL FRONT TIRE TIRES SET 25 X 550 X 15 LOOK READ CLOSELY
MOROSO DRAG SPECIAL FRONT TIRE TIRES SET 25 X 550 X 15 LOOK READ CLOSELY
Paypal   US $120.00
RHTF VINTAGE FRANCIE DRESS TO 1967 ICED BLUE FRONT GOOD BACK NOT GOOD READ
RHTF VINTAGE FRANCIE DRESS TO 1967 ICED BLUE FRONT GOOD BACK NOT GOOD READ
Paypal   US $8.99
SUZUKI FRONT FENDER K10 5311c19 11 15 A50 MA T TA TB M 12 READ S31 32 125 150
SUZUKI FRONT FENDER K10 5311c19 11 15 A50 MA T TA TB M 12 READ S31 32 125 150
Paypal   US $59.00
T10 6000K 52 SMD LED BMW E87 E82 128i 135i M1 Interior Dome Map Lights PackageJ
T10 6000K 52 SMD LED BMW E87 E82 128i 135i M1 Interior Dome Map Lights PackageJ
Paypal   US $63.99
Red 4 Lights LED Interior Package Dodge Charger Magnum
Red 4 Lights LED Interior Package Dodge Charger Magnum
Paypal   US $23.99
Clic Goggles 150x Magnetic Front Connection Reading Glasses Clear Frames
Clic Goggles 150x Magnetic Front Connection Reading Glasses Clear Frames
Paypal   US $29.95
2 Pieces Brembo 25549 Front Disc Brake Rotors Please Read Notes In Catalog
2 Pieces Brembo 25549 Front Disc Brake Rotors Please Read Notes In Catalog
Paypal   US $76.56
Blue 4 Lights LED Interior Package Dodge Charger Magnum
Blue 4 Lights LED Interior Package Dodge Charger Magnum
Paypal   US $23.99
DANA BUCHMAN sz 10 stretch pants flat front back zip lined Read details NICE
DANA BUCHMAN sz 10 stretch pants flat front back zip lined Read details NICE
Paypal   US $14.00
White 4 Lights SMD LED Interior Package Charger Magnum
White 4 Lights SMD LED Interior Package Charger Magnum
Paypal   US $35.99
USED Shimano Dura Ace BR 7800 Road Bike Brake Cycling Front and Rear PLEASE READ
USED Shimano Dura Ace BR 7800 Road Bike Brake Cycling Front and Rear PLEASE READ
Paypal   US $179.99
USED Shimano Ultegra BR 6500 Front Road Brake Caliper Cycling PLEASE READ
USED Shimano Ultegra BR 6500 Front Road Brake Caliper Cycling PLEASE READ
Paypal   US $49.99
525 PC Media Dashboard Front Panel Card READERS SATA USB20 TN LCD READ NEW
525 PC Media Dashboard Front Panel Card READERS SATA USB20 TN LCD READ NEW
Paypal   US $26.68
Clic Goggles 175x Magnetic Front Connection Reading Glasses Tortoise Frames
Clic Goggles 175x Magnetic Front Connection Reading Glasses Tortoise Frames
Paypal   US $29.95
2 pair Easy wear LADY READING GLASSES plastic front with design metal temples
2 pair Easy wear LADY READING GLASSES plastic front with design metal temples
Paypal   US $23.00
White 4 Light LED Interior Package Dodge Charger Magnum
White 4 Light LED Interior Package Dodge Charger Magnum
Paypal   US $23.99
MAGNETIC BRIDGE FRONT CONNECTION READING GLASSES
MAGNETIC BRIDGE FRONT CONNECTION READING GLASSES
Paypal   US $15.99
BMW E60 E61 5 SERIES FRONT COCKPIT INTERIOR MAP READING LIGHT M5
BMW E60 E61 5 SERIES FRONT COCKPIT INTERIOR MAP READING LIGHT M5
Paypal   US $23.56
Front disc brakes 70 81 camaro firebird CONVERSION nova chevelle skylark gto 350
Front disc brakes 70 81 camaro firebird CONVERSION nova chevelle skylark gto 350
Paypal   US $65.00
Vintage Schwinn Collegiate bicycle bike Front and Read Fenders Parts
Vintage Schwinn Collegiate bicycle bike Front and Read Fenders Parts
Paypal   US $9.99
NEW Shimano Deore XT HB M775 Mountain Bike Front Hub Disc Silver 36H PLEASE READ
NEW Shimano Deore XT HB M775 Mountain Bike Front Hub Disc Silver 36H PLEASE READ
Paypal   US $19.99
Clic Goggles 200x Magnetic Front Connection Reading Glasses Clear Frames
Clic Goggles 200x Magnetic Front Connection Reading Glasses Clear Frames
Paypal   US $29.95
1800330 Jeep JK 2007 2012 SKID PLATE FRONT BLACK Under Armour Read Descrip
1800330 Jeep JK 2007 2012 SKID PLATE FRONT BLACK Under Armour Read Descrip
Paypal   US $158.75
FORD MUSTANG 1994 1998 FRONT PARK LENS PLEASE READ COMMENTS
FORD MUSTANG 1994 1998 FRONT PARK LENS PLEASE READ COMMENTS
Paypal   US $29.99
Blue 4 Lights LED Interior Package Chrysler 300 300C
Blue 4 Lights LED Interior Package Chrysler 300 300C
Paypal   US $23.99
Firestone Keystone Drag Race Wheel Set Ford Read Chevy Front SET OF 4
Firestone Keystone Drag Race Wheel Set Ford Read Chevy Front SET OF 4
Paypal   US $15.50
White 4 Lights LED Interior Package Chrysler 300 300C
White 4 Lights LED Interior Package Chrysler 300 300C
Paypal   US $23.99
VW Golf 5 6 Plus Jetta Passat CC white Front Seat Reading Light no error free
VW Golf 5 6 Plus Jetta Passat CC white Front Seat Reading Light no error free
Paypal   US $45.00
Men Funny Biker Patch T Shirts 11Colours If You Can Read This Front Rear Print
Men Funny Biker Patch T Shirts 11Colours If You Can Read This Front Rear Print
Paypal   US $18.84
Error Free White 128 SMD LED Interior Lights Package Mercedes C E Class Sedan 4D
Error Free White 128 SMD LED Interior Lights Package Mercedes C E Class Sedan 4D
Paypal   US $64.99
525 PC Media Dashboard Front Panel Card READRE ESATA USB 20 MEMLEY CARD READ
525 PC Media Dashboard Front Panel Card READRE ESATA USB 20 MEMLEY CARD READ
Paypal   US $27.68
525 PC Media Dashboard Front Panel Card Read USB 20 SATA memory card readers
525 PC Media Dashboard Front Panel Card Read USB 20 SATA memory card readers
Paypal   US $26.58
NEW Shimano FD R770 Road Braze on Front Derailleur Double 10 Speed PLEASE READ
NEW Shimano FD R770 Road Braze on Front Derailleur Double 10 Speed PLEASE READ
Paypal   US $24.99
HP DV7 4000 LCD Front Bezel READ
HP DV7 4000 LCD Front Bezel READ
Paypal   US $32.90
2001 2004 MAZDA TRIBUTE FRONT MAP READING INTERIOR LAMP LIGHT PANEL CONSOLE ROOF
2001 2004 MAZDA TRIBUTE FRONT MAP READING INTERIOR LAMP LIGHT PANEL CONSOLE ROOF
Paypal   US $59.99
Ford Front Wheel Alignment Chart Caster Readings 1975 6
Ford Front Wheel Alignment Chart Caster Readings 1975 6
Paypal   US $9.00
Toshiba A215 156 LCD Screen Plastic Front Bezel Trim Defect Read AP019000A00
Toshiba A215 156 LCD Screen Plastic Front Bezel Trim Defect Read AP019000A00
Paypal   US $39.99
BMW 1993 E32 7 SERIES FRONT VANITY READING LIGHTS
BMW 1993 E32 7 SERIES FRONT VANITY READING LIGHTS
Paypal   US $9.41
1999 2005 Volkswagen Jetta Interior Ceiling Light front map reading lamp OEM
1999 2005 Volkswagen Jetta Interior Ceiling Light front map reading lamp OEM
Paypal   US $7.49
Team associated TC6 C Hub Front and Read STEERING KNUCKLE
Team associated TC6 C Hub Front and Read STEERING KNUCKLE
Paypal   US $30.00
YAMAHA 67 68 69 70 71 VINTAGE ROUND FRONT LIGHT BEAM FREE SHIP READ
YAMAHA 67 68 69 70 71 VINTAGE ROUND FRONT LIGHT BEAM FREE SHIP READ
Paypal   US $59.99
Porsche 964 Carrera FRONT Brake Disc COAT Z read me
Porsche 964 Carrera FRONT Brake Disc COAT Z read me
Paypal   US $233.90
98 05 PASSAT FRONT MAP VANITY READING DOME LIGHT ROOF
98 05 PASSAT FRONT MAP VANITY READING DOME LIGHT ROOF
Paypal   US $19.99
98 05 PASSAT FRONT VANITY MAP READING DOME LIGHT ROOF
98 05 PASSAT FRONT VANITY MAP READING DOME LIGHT ROOF
Paypal   US $19.99
BMW OEM E53 X5 SUV FRONT DOME MAP READING LIGHT CENTER BLACK TRIM PANEL COVER
BMW OEM E53 X5 SUV FRONT DOME MAP READING LIGHT CENTER BLACK TRIM PANEL COVER
Paypal   US $50.00
525 LCD USB 20 30 SATA Media Dashboard Front Card Read Panel
525 LCD USB 20 30 SATA Media Dashboard Front Card Read Panel
Paypal   US $36.99
BMW E39 Light dome map reading front DOME LAMP LIGHT OEM 525 528 540 740
BMW E39 Light dome map reading front DOME LAMP LIGHT OEM 525 528 540 740
Paypal   US $20.00
SKIROULE FRONT 1 SPROKET FOR ROUND SHAFT 8 TOOTH S 250 72 AND OTHER READ
SKIROULE FRONT 1 SPROKET FOR ROUND SHAFT 8 TOOTH S 250 72 AND OTHER READ
Paypal   US $79.99
Dell Latitude D520 14 LCD Front Bezel JG815 READ
Dell Latitude D520 14 LCD Front Bezel JG815 READ
Paypal   US $1.25
Suzuki Front Pads New Two Sets For Read Description
Suzuki Front Pads New Two Sets For Read Description
Paypal   US $19.95
BMW 745i 745Li E65 E66 FRONT INTERIOR READING LIGHT OEM 2002
BMW 745i 745Li E65 E66 FRONT INTERIOR READING LIGHT OEM 2002
Paypal   US $40.00
93 94 95 96 97 98 SAAB 9000 FRONT CENTER MAP READING LIGHT ASSEMBLY WITH SWITCH
93 94 95 96 97 98 SAAB 9000 FRONT CENTER MAP READING LIGHT ASSEMBLY WITH SWITCH
Paypal   US $8.09
BMW E60 E61 5 SERIES FRONT COCKPIT INTERIOR MAP READING LIGHT OEM 6 962 058
BMW E60 E61 5 SERIES FRONT COCKPIT INTERIOR MAP READING LIGHT OEM 6 962 058
Paypal   US $31.42
BMW E46 330CI CONVERTIBLE FRONT READING LIGHT 8364929 OEM 2001
BMW E46 330CI CONVERTIBLE FRONT READING LIGHT 8364929 OEM 2001
Paypal   US $35.00
Mutiny on the Bounty Blu ray DVD DigiBook Visible Front Cover Wear Read AD
Mutiny on the Bounty Blu ray DVD DigiBook Visible Front Cover Wear Read AD
Paypal   US $13.99
Toshiba Satellite A305 LCD Front Bezel V000122070 READ
Toshiba Satellite A305 LCD Front Bezel V000122070 READ
Paypal   US $8.24
BUMPER CUDA FRONT E BODY MOPAR 70 71 72 READ ME AMD
BUMPER CUDA FRONT E BODY MOPAR 70 71 72 READ ME AMD
Paypal   US $269.96
BUMPER CHALLENGER FRONT E BODY MOPAR 70 71 72 READ ME AMD
BUMPER CHALLENGER FRONT E BODY MOPAR 70 71 72 READ ME AMD
Paypal   US $269.96
F150 F 150 TAN FRONT Overhead Storage Sunglasses Dome Light Reading Map 04 08
F150 F 150 TAN FRONT Overhead Storage Sunglasses Dome Light Reading Map 04 08
Paypal   US $75.00
DOME MAP READING LIGHT FORD TAURUS 2001 FRONT
DOME MAP READING LIGHT FORD TAURUS 2001 FRONT
Paypal   US $16.19
5in FL Type Speedometers 224060 Ratio Front Wheel Drive and Read Switch 91 9
5in FL Type Speedometers 224060 Ratio Front Wheel Drive and Read Switch 91 9
Paypal   US $104.31
SA VS310 Front Speaker SS FVS310 Read First Sony Make Offer
SA VS310 Front Speaker SS FVS310 Read First Sony Make Offer
Paypal   US $53.99
White 4 Lights SMD LED Interior Package Chrysler 300C
White 4 Lights SMD LED Interior Package Chrysler 300C
Paypal   US $35.99
Red 168 194 2825 5 SMD LED Interior Map Dome Lights 11
Red 168 194 2825 5 SMD LED Interior Map Dome Lights 11
Paypal   US $13.99
95 98 96 97 ACURA TL OEM TAN FRONT DOME MAP READING LIGHT
95 98 96 97 ACURA TL OEM TAN FRONT DOME MAP READING LIGHT
Paypal   US $26.99
Elmer Gantry Minor Front Cover Damage Read Ad DVD is factory Sealed
Elmer Gantry Minor Front Cover Damage Read Ad DVD is factory Sealed
Paypal   US $4.49
BMW E60 525i FRONT INTERIOR READING LIGHT OEM 2004
BMW E60 525i FRONT INTERIOR READING LIGHT OEM 2004
Paypal   US $45.00
2006 POLARIS SPORTSMAN 500 EFI X2 FRONT RIGHT STRUT READ DESCRIPTION
2006 POLARIS SPORTSMAN 500 EFI X2 FRONT RIGHT STRUT READ DESCRIPTION
Paypal   US $35.00
NOS MOPAR 1984 85 86 87 FRONT HEADER READING LAMP H K
NOS MOPAR 1984 85 86 87 FRONT HEADER READING LAMP H K
Paypal   US $39.99
19 01 1957 Reading v Colchester United Folded Writing On Front No obvious f
19 01 1957 Reading v Colchester United Folded Writing On Front No obvious f
Paypal   US $4.70
FIAT MULTIPLA 19 JTD FRONT INTERIOR LIGHT MAP READING
FIAT MULTIPLA 19 JTD FRONT INTERIOR LIGHT MAP READING
Paypal   US $31.42

Front Reading

Reading Buddies: Its Effect on Emotional Intelligence and Reading Comprehension

Reading Buddies: Its Effect on Emotional Intelligence and Reading Comprehension

It is 8:15 on a Friday morning and half of my sixth grade students are preparing materials for their trek to Mrs. Stewart’s third grade classroom, while the other half prepares for their third grade visitors.  Mrs. Stewart and Mr. Alvarado have teamed to provide a little Reading Buddy program for their classes.  Every Friday morning Mr. Alvarado’s 6th grade students take their third grade reading buddy through the lesson plan that was created the day before.  The lesson plan outline consists of 5-10 minutes of phonics review/instruction, 15-20 minutes of basic sight word development, and 30 minutes of shared reading and comprehension strategies.  The hour is intensive with lots of conversation, laughter, and excitement about reading.  Mrs. Stewart and Mr. Alvarado frequently discuss the challenges of such a program, but on a larger scale celebrate the positive activities taking place.  Celebrations included the improvement in sight word development; a similar result was found in a study by Butler (1999), improvement in reading ability and confidence, improved self-confidence and empathy of our students, and an overall student excitement over this activity, to name a few.   In point of fact, research supports the informal observations of Mrs. Stewart and Mr. Alvarado.  For example, Bower (2001) suggests students gravitate towards reading with a buddy as opposed to reading by themselves.

 

As a reading teacher, I could not imagine operating my sixth grade classroom absent a Reading Buddy program for my students and the affect it could have on improving the reading ability of their little buddies.  The No Child Left Behind Act (NCLB) of 2001has the potential to exclude a program, such as reading buddies, from being a component to a rich literature environment.  In a study conducted by Bower (2001), third grade students, the experimental group, were paired and subjected to six weeks of reading buddy comprehension activities.  The control group, an equal number of students, read and completed the comprehension activities independently.  The findings, although not statistically significant, supported the researcher’s hypothesis that the experiment group would outperform the control group in improved comprehension skills.  Equally, Cazden (1988) found reading partners with an emphasis on literature discussions to be an effective component to a reading program.  Because NCLB is supported by the findings of the National Reading Panel (NRP) of which its research methodology is credentialed as Scientifically Based Reading Research (SBBR), the NCLB legislation has the support in place to potentially discourage, if not prohibit, teachers from using Reading Buddies.  Because of its influence on reading instruction, it’s important to understand the mission and the finding of the National Reading Panel.

National Reading Panel

In 1997, the Director of the National Institute of Child Health and Human Development (NICHD) was given the directive by congress to ascertain the state of reading instruction programs in the United States of America.  The request was adhered to, and as a result a National Reading Panel was convened.  The charge of the panel was to:

…assess the status of research-based knowledge, including the effectiveness of various approaches to teaching children to read.” The panel was charged with providing a report that “should present the panel’s conclusions, an indication of the readiness for application in the classroom of the results of this research, and, if

appropriate, a strategy for rapidly disseminating this information to facilitate effective reading instruction in the schools. (NICHD, 2000, p. 1-1)

One of the challenges that faced the NRP was the timeline to meet its directive.  When faced with the 100,000 studies, it devised methods to focus on what it considered to be the best.  Its solution was to establish a set of prerequisites in the form of focus topics and guiding questions to consider when identifying reading research studies that best fit the directive of congress.  The focus topics chosen were Alphabetics, Fluency, Comprehension, Teacher Education and Reading Instruction, and Computer Technology and Reading Instruction.  The guiding questions considered were as follows:

  1. 1. Does instruction in phonemic awareness improve reading? If so, how is this         instruction best provided?

2. Does phonics instruction improve reading achievement? If so, how is this instruction best provided?

  1. 3. Does guided repeated oral reading instruction improve fluency and reading   comprehension? If so, how is this instruction best provided?
  2. 4. Does vocabulary instruction improve reading achievement? If so, how is this   instruction best provided?

5. Does comprehension strategy instruction improve reading? If so, how is this instruction best provided?

6. Do programs that increase the amount of children’s independent reading improve reading achievement and motivation? If so, how is this instruction best

provided?

7. Does teacher education influence how effective teachers are at teaching children to read? If so, how is this instruction best provided?

In addition to the focus topics and guiding questions used to narrow the scope of the research, other characteristics were incorporated in the selecting of the research studies to be analyzed.  A concern that many should have about this process is that many research studies were not considered in the analysis of establishing the report to congress.  As an example, 364 potential studies were available for analysis in oral reading instruction, after inspection through the NRP’s research methodology criteria, only 16 studies were accepted and quantified to be a meta-analysis (NICHD, 2000, p. 12).  This example represents approximately 95% of the non-acceptance rate of the studies available for analysis to the NRP and should have been an indicator to the potential flaw inherent in the process.  Garan (2001) suggests that the NRP conducted a meta-analysis on so few studies because of the narrow model of research they included. 

Another key finding in my research as to the possible inconsistency of the NRP’s research methodology exists within guiding question number six.  This question focuses on whether independent reading improves reading achievement and motivation.  However, Yatvin (2003) reports that the NRP did not have enough time to follow through and research certain focus topics including motivational factors in learning to read.  Additionally, one of the more important focus topics considered in selecting the reading research studies to be analyzed was comprehension.  However, Garan (2001) stated “the panel did not include reading comprehension or the application of phonics skills in authentic literacy events as necessary criteria in establishing what it termed a "general literacy" outcome.” (p. 6).  These examples need to be considered as it establishes a question as to the accuracy of the report generated by the NRP and significantly draws the validity of the report into question.

NRP and Sound Research

A consideration that I wish to instill in this position paper is that a Reading Buddy program can improve Emotional Intelligence (EQ) and reading comprehension.  This position paper is given strength in that the NRP report did not specifically dismiss these concepts, but rather it is my contention that because the NRP failed to follow through with the original outline of areas to research, opportunities for activities that promote EQ and reading comprehension should be considered.  In addition, the many questions that challenge the consistency and integrity of the NRP are validated again when consideration of the response to the NRP’s lack of time to research areas of motivation and comprehension are weighed.  The NRP (Garan, 2001) acknowledged the studies that it used in its research to determine a general literacy outcome did not include reading comprehension.  In its investigation of key questions to consider in choosing research studies, the NRP identified the following as guiding question number six:  Do programs that increase the amount of children’s independent reading improve reading achievement and motivation? If so, how is this instruction best provided?

            According to the National Reading Panel summary (NRP, 2000, p. 19) a time limitation resulted in evaluating the research for purposes of meeting the congressional report deadline date.  As a result the NRP was unable to follow through with its commitment of researching topics that fell within the parameters of the guiding question regarding reading achievement and motivation.  This omission of this criterion does one of two things; first it has the potential of insinuating that motivation is not an important element of a sound reading program, or second, it can leave open an opportunity for research on this particular element.  The position of this paper will focus on the latter and provide research on the area of Reading Buddies. 

Reading Buddies

  1. Understanding the success that reading buddies can bring to a school makes it vitally important to understand how to incorporate such a program.

Incorporating a successful Reading Buddy Program

  1. In addition, lesson design instruction, in reference to amount of time available for the reading activity, was important to meeting the goal of the reading assignment (Friedland & Truesdell, 2004). 

The coaching big buddy’s to read to and with their little buddy is an important element of the Reading Buddy Program.  Big buddy’s were responsible to model and solicit responsible reading strategies of fluency and expression.  Others strategies required during this reading buddy program were prediction, discussion, and comprehension (Block & Dellamura, 2000/2001).   An important consideration to analyze here is that many different strategies are employed to the teaching of reading with comprehension being the winner.  As Garan and DeVoogd (2008) notes in their Sustained Silent Reading paper, the NRP had trouble finding research on SSR largely in part because it focused on research that relied on component-skills model of reading as well as its focus on fluency and not comprehension as an outcome (Paris, 2005).  The NRP specifically states that it ran out of time in identifying studies that researched comprehension.  It is my contention, based on the facts, the NRP was destined in finding inaccurate results in the role comprehension plays in reading instruction.

To further increase the opportunities of comprehension, the big buddy was provided with a list of guided questions that would act as a catalyst for comprehension strategies (Block & Dellamura, 2000/2001).  Theurer and Schmidt (2008) cite the following guided questions:

“Does this book remind you of another book you have read?

Who was your favorite character? Why?

What is the message in this book?

What was your favorite part of this story?

How would you change the ending of this story?

What character would you like to be? Why?

What is the problem in this story? How was it resolved?

Did you like this book? Why? Give two good reasons!” (p. 26)

 

Reading buddy programs have been shown to improve the reading ability of students with disabilities.  Garan (2001) cited findings from the Reports of the Subgroup, (pp. 2-96, 2-135) stating, “…effectiveness of systematic phonics instruction were derived from studies conducted in many classrooms with typical classroom teachers and typical American or English-speaking students from a variety of backgrounds. . .  Thus the results of the analysis are indicative of what can be accomplished when systematic phonics programs are implemented in today's classrooms.”  This statement and the NRP’s research failed to demonstrate how students with disabilities would benefit from such programs.  Buter (1999) reported successful results on her Class-Wide Peer Tutoring (CWPT) program.  The program called for tutoring buddies to be paired with students of disabilities.   Findings included a one year growth in sight word development and academic and social growth as well.  Butler indicated that peer tutoring programs can be structured to benefit all students with additional successful components in the areas of academic and social development.  Butler’s findings, one research study that took me about  1 hour to locate, add value to the possibility of reading buddy programs and what they add to improving academic and social intelligences. 

The big buddy reading program’s goal of improving the reading potential of their little reading buddy was not the lone result that the director’s had in mind when venturing into this arena.  An additional element that reading buddies has the potential of improving is one’s emotional intelligence.  Goleman qualifies to be emotional intelligence: getting along with others, self-motivation, persistence, controlling impulses, empathizing, and regulating one’s moods (Goleman, 1996).  Theurer and Schmidt (2008) share an important focus of the training is the interacting with their buddy.  Big buddies were mentored in the importance of greeting their little buddy with a smile and to say goodbye when they left.  The big buddies also practiced encouragements that complimented their buddy as well as strategies on what to do when their buddy was not listening, cooperating, or behaving inappropriately. 

  1. Following are some of the flaws to the brain research used to posture the establishment of the NCLB act.

Flawed  Brain Research

The Reading First Program, a derivative of the NRP findings, was an initiative set forth by President George W. Bush based on scientific brain research. This research has some flaws in that its findings were, largely in part, due to functional magnetic resonance imaging (fmri), a process to measure differences in the brain activity (Willis, 2007).  . 

The issue with this fmri process is that the researcher only considered one portion of the brain’s complex reading network.  The study, favoring the NRP’s position, was that the study was conducted in a region of the brain that is known to be more active during phonics processing (Willis, 2007).  They say that when something looks and smells like a rat, it probably is a rat.  Well, an interesting fact is that this portion of the brain became more active when the students tested on phonics processing activities.  Again, if the goal is to learn constrained skills then fine, but reading involves comprehension and comprehension involves the development of unconstrained skills.  Willis (2007) suggests that, “we cannot generalization from these findings that all reading improves when the so-called phonics center becomes more active.” (p. 3).

Willis (2007) reports that the brain glitch theory treatment of reading as an isolated and independent cognitive process is counterproductive to the complex process connecting multiple learning and association centers in the brain.  Reading, at the minimum involves the limbic system, occipital cortex, associational subcortical frontal lobe centers, and medial temporal lobe and should really be aligned to instructional practices that stimulate multiple brain areas.

In addition, Willis (2007) cites (Brembs, Lorenzetti, Reyes, Baxter, & Byrne, 2002) having found interesting research on dopamine, brain proteins that are released and carry information throughout the brain.  Dopamine release has been found to increase during pleasurable and positive experiences.  Willis (2007) suggests that early studies show the amount of dopamine released by the brain increases during activities that involve playing, exercising, laughing, being read to, and recognizing personal achievements.  It is my contention, based on the reading buddy research, that opportunities like these are abundant.

The education literature has included theories about the effects of emotion on language acquisition for decades. Dulay and Burt (1977) and Krashen (1982) proposed that strong positive emotion reinforces learning, whereas excessive levels of stress and anxiety interfere with learning.

  1. Many are feeling that equally important is the educating of the “whole” child. (Rattigan, 2007).    

As an example of benefits in educating the whole child, Rattigan (2007) shares that educating the “whole” child includes social and emotional aspects of learning which are strengthened in resilience skills.  Henderson & Milstein (1996) define resilience to be “the capacity to spring back, rebound, successfully adapt in the face of adversity, and develop social, academic, and vocational competence despite exposure to severe stress or simply stress that is inherent in today’s world” (p.7).  This idea of resiliency is one that can be taught and learned via the building of one’s emotional intelligence.

Emotional Intelligence

In addition to successes noted in academics, reading buddy programs demonstrated equal amounts of success in the areas of emotional Intelligence.  Emotional Intelligence (EQ) is a term coined by Yale psychologist Peter Salovey and University of New Hampshire’s John Mayer.  They describe EQ as the qualities one possesses to control one’s own emotions, empathize with the emotions of others, and regulate one’s feeling in times of crisis to improve the quality of life one lives (Gibbs,1995).  Goleman offers that all students need to be made aware of emotional intelligence characteristics within the educational environment (Pool, 1997).

Conventional wisdom asserts that IQ is the best predictor of future success. Current research is suggesting that IQ may only be responsible for 20% of a person’s success, leaving 80% to other forces.  Those forces are what Goleman suggests to be emotional intelligence: getting along with others, self-motivation, persistence, controlling impulses, empathizing, and regulating one’s moods (Goleman, 1996).  The challenge then becomes for school staffs to not only increase test scores, but also assist in increasing student’s emotional intelligence. 

            The dilemma many educators confront when wanting to incorporate social-emotional curricula into the school day is that it challenges the traditional core curriculums (Harrington-Lueker, 1995).  However, Goleman’s theory of emotional intelligence has not come without criticism from his colleagues.  Margarita Muniz, principal at Raphael Hernandez school in Boston, feels that there is not enough evidence of what constitutes a sound emotional-development program or how to even measure emotional aptitude.  Other researchers argue that it is premature to insist that emotional intelligence can be

taught like polynomials or that these skills will help improve academic achievement.  Linda Baker, guidance counselor at West Mills Middle School, New Haven Connecticut, says, “Finding time to teach EQ in an already packed school schedule is tough.  It is equally difficult to find teachers who are adept at emotional skill building” (Harrington-

  1. It is not either-or, it is both” (Harrington-Lueker, 1995, p. 3).  

When considering what types of learning should be taking place inside of an educational institution, all stakeholders to the future leaders of our society should contemplate the function of the brain.  The brain is composed of three main parts; the neo-cortex, limbic system, and brain stem.  It is in the limbic system that all of our emotions are controlled.  Within the limbic system are found two amygdala’s, which are responsible for receiving and sending all emotional messages.  The amygdala’s are always communicating with the neo-cortex, which is responsible for analytical and verbal tasks.  Our analytical thinking is always controlled by our emotions (Pool, 1997).  Individuals who are mature and healthy have better connections with their amygdala’s, or emotional responses, therefore allowing the neo-cortex to make better decisions.  Children who are constantly angry, frustrated, or subjected to bad environments experience interference by the amygdala, therefore making it hard for them to concentrate and thus learn.  Because the amygdala doesn’t mature until a child is 15 or 16, we have

many opportunities to teach children how to handle their feelings (Pool, 1997).

Today’s children have created a new perspective for schools to consider when approaching the curricular and teaching strategies.  In addition to teaching reading, writing, and math curriculum, schools are now becoming a center for social learning as well.  Because children appear to be receiving less and less guidance and direction from their homes and communities, schools are having to commit themselves to creating an infrastructure that can address the student’s social and emotional deficiencies (Lantieri & Patti, 1996).  As educators begin to brainstorm how to handle this decline of social adeptness, they along with parents and administrators worry about tradition.  They are concerned that devoting class time to addressing this deficit will hurt traditional academics and ultimately create a decline in test scores (Elias & Butler, 1997).

There is still much to learn on how the brain learns and therefore, it is irresponsible to assume that any instructional strategy is best for learning to read.  For the present moment teachers of reading must be guided by their professional knowledge base and their never-ending study of scientific evidence on how the brain responds to stimuli.  There exists promising areas of research and practice.

Putting It All Together

I have often wondered what it would be like to not have been able to take my sixth grade students through our Little Buddy Reading Program.  I was witness to my students benefitting in both Emotional Intelligence and Academic Intelligence.  For several, the academic success came as a result of strengthening their emotional intelligence.  My third grade colleague would also share, and had data to support her findings, that her third grade students grew in reading levels which required comprehension to increase. 

The National Reading Panel having conducted its research with its interpretation of what constitutes sound SBBR, had a huge fan base in former President George W. Bush in creating reading instruction policy.  This support system, in all honesty, should have prevented me from practicing the reading buddy program, but I felt it important for reading improvement and emotional intelligence growth. 

In hindsight to the many flaws that have been discovered regarding the NRP, I find myself dancing in the rain, if you will, as to my decision in finding the time to make the reading buddy program work.  First, the NRP established, in its own definition, a meta-analysis of the reading research.  Its error was that it failed to recall that a meta-analysis is a comparison of results that encompass many and varied research studies; varied in the sense that it used relatively obscure methods in its study selection. In this weeding out process or selective process of research topics, the NRP failed to find research studies regarding comprehension.  This omission established a hole in its committed research of comprehension and thus could have possibly omitted the benefits of a reading buddy program.  One of the biggest blunders, if I may be so frank, of the NRP is its admission of running out of time to research studies on motivation and comprehension.  Reading Buddy programs have shown to strengthen motivation and comprehension skills.

A sound reading buddy program has been shown to include activities that involve peer to peer support in the area of reading.  The goal of my sixth grade reading buddy program was for the big buddy to assist his little buddy in reading and comprehending the story through strategies that support reading and comprehension.  Some of these activities involved spelling practice, phonemic awareness strategies, fluency practice, and reading comprehension strategies.  Many of these activities offer both constrained and unconstrained skill practice and development.  The NRP’s research was based on constrained skill research, which offers another reason as to why many research studies were omitted.  In addition to omitting research on comprehension, the NRP was selective in its brain research to support their findings on reading achievement.

A main poster child of the NRP findings was the establishment of The Reading First Program, an initiative enacted by former President George W. Bush.  I recall being a reading first school and many times was questioned about my reading buddy program and how it was not an approved NCLB practice that improved reading achievement.  This research was based on flawed scientific brain research that only considered one portion of the brain’s complex reading network.  In addition, this research favored the NRP’s purpose of finding research that showed reading achievement occurring in the brain region that is most active during phonics processing.  Again, we are reminded that The Reading First Program was a phonics based curriculum, and from first-hand experience it was a “sleeper,” but, it did however fit the NRP’s bill of identifying research that focused on constrained skills.   The NRP’s failure in this thought process is that comprehension is a crucial criterion for reading achievement.  The Reading Buddy Program has proven to be positive for comprehension and as an additional component has been positive for improving emotional intelligence.

            Reading Buddy Programs involve students working together for a common purpose of reading development.  Evidences have demonstrated that brain activity is intensified during this process that involves laughter, being read to, and receiving confirmation of good work.  All of these attributes of what a Reading Buddy Program has to offer is associated with Emotional Intelligence.

Emotional Intelligence, as defined by Goleman, is the ability to get along with others, be self-motivated, empathize with others, control impulses, and regulate one’s moods.  A need for emotional intelligence to be taught in school is found in research that demonstrates the success of person amounts to 20% of academic intelligence and 80% to emotional intelligence.  Understanding this relationship of intelligences to success would prompt educators to planning their teaching on lessons that espouse these two types of intelligences.  Reading buddy programs can be a way to compliment the two intelligences.

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Bibliography

Block, C.C., & Dellamura, R.J. (2000/2001). Better book buddies.

The Reading Teacher, 54(4), 364–370.

 

Bower, N.L. (2001).  The Effects of Reading with a Partner and Participating in a

            Literature Discussion on Reading Comprehension.  Dissertation p.5.

 

Butler,F.M. (1999).  Reading Partners: Students can Help Each Other Learn to Read! 

Education and Treatment of Children Vol. 22, No. 4, 1-12

 

Cazden, C.B., (1988).  Classroom Discourse: The Language Of Teaching and Learning.

Portsmouth, NH: Heinemann.

 

Dulay, H., & Burt, M. (1977). Remarks on creativity in language acquisition.

In M. Burt, H. Dulay, & M. Finocchiaro (Eds.), Viewpoints on English as

a Second Language (pp. 74–83). New York: Regents.

 

Elias, M.J., Bruene-Butler, L., Blum, L., & Schuyler, T. (1997, May). How to

 launch a social and emotional learning program. Educational Leadership,

 15-19.

 

Friedland, E.S. & Truesdell, K.S. (2004). Kids reading together: Ensuring the success of

 a buddy reading program. The Reading Teacher, 58(1), 76–79.

doi:10.1598/RT.58.1.7

 

Garan, E. (2001). Beyond the smoke and mirrors: A critique of the

            National Reading Panel report on phonics. Phi Delta Kappan,

           82(7), 500–506.

 

Garan, E., DeVoogd, G.  (2008). The Benefits of Sustained Silent Reading: Scientific

Research and Common Sense Converge.  The Reading Teacher, 62(4), pp. 336-344.

 

Gibbs, N. (1995, October). The EQ Factor. Time, 60-68.

 

Goleman, D. (1996, May). Emotional intelligence. Why it can matter more than

IQ. Learning, 24, (6), 49-50.

 

 

Greenberg, M. T., Weissberg, R.P., O’Brien, M. U., Zins, J. E., Fredericks, L., Resnik H.,

 & Elias, M.J. (2003, June/July).  Enhancing school-based prevention and youth

development through coordinated social, emotional, and academic learning. 

Amrican Psychologist, 58, 466-474.

Harrington-Lueker, D. (1997, September). Students need emotional intelligence.

 The Education Digest, 7-11.

 

Henderson, N. & Milstein, M.M. (1996).  Resiliency in schools – Making it happen for

 students and educators.  Thousand Oaks, Ca: Corwin Press, Inc.

Krashen, S. (1982). Theory versus practice in language training. In R. W.

 Blair (Ed.), Innovative Approaches to Language Teaching (p. 25).

Rowley, MA: Newbury House.

Kreuger, E. & Braun, B. (1998-1999). Books and Buddies: Peers tutoring peers. The

Reading Teacher Vol. 52, No. 4, 410-414

 

Lanteri, L., & Patti, J. (1996, September). The road to peace in our schools.

Educational Leadership, 28-31.

 

National Institute of Child Health and Human Development. (2000). Report of the

National Reading Panel. Teaching children to read: An evidence-based

assessment  of the scientific research literature on reading and its implications for

 reading instruction (NIH  Publication No. 00-4769). Washington, DC: U.S.

 Government Printing Office.

 

  1. Reading 

    Research Quarterly, Vol. 40 No. 2.

Pool, C.R. (1997, May). Up with emotional health. Educational Leadership, 54,

 12-14.

Puca, M., & Schmalt, H. (1999). Task enjoyment: A mediator between

 achievement motives and performance. Motivation and Emotion,

23(1), 15–29.

 

 

Rattigan, J. (2007). The Right Side of the No Child Left Behind One elementary school’s

implementation of emotional intelligence initiatives. Dissertation Abstracts

            International, (UMI 3268196)

 

Theurer, J, & Schmidt, K. (2008). Coaching Reading Buddies for Success.  The Reading

Teacher 62(3), pp. 261-264

 

Vygotsky,  L.S. (1978). Mind in Society. Cambridge, M.A: Harvard University

   Press.

Willis, J. (2007). Special Topic / The Gully in the “Brain Glitch” Theory.  Improving

Instruction for Students with Learning Needs, 64(5), pp. 68-73.

 

Yatvin, J. (2003).  I Told You So!  The Misinterpretation and Misuse of The National

            Reading Panel Report, Education Week, 1-6.

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

About the Author

My name is Johnny Alvarado and I am a middle school principal. I am currently working on my doctorate degree and have an assingment of attempting to public an article. This my first article in attempting to publish, so I am awaiting any first attempt comments you may have to share.


Flapper Reading in front of Fire


Flapper Reading in front of Fire


$34.99


Flapper Reading in front of Fire - Giclee Print

Woman Reading in Front of a Mirror


Woman Reading in Front of a Mirror


$34.99


Hallie Champlin Hyde Woman Reading in Front of a Mirror - Giclee Print

Lady Reading Pouring Tea in Front of Fireplace


Lady Reading Pouring Tea in Front of Fireplace


$79.99


Lady Reading Pouring Tea in Front of Fireplace - Premium Photographic Print

A Woman Sitting and Reading in Front of a Sai Ho Storefront


A Woman Sitting and Reading in Front of a Sai Ho Storefront


$79.99


A Woman Sitting and Reading in Front of a Sai Ho Storefront - Premium Photographic Print

Reading


Reading


$17.99


Reading

Two Boys Lying on Floor in Front of Fireplace, Reading Book


Two Boys Lying on Floor in Front of Fireplace, Reading Book


$24.99


Two Boys Lying on Floor in Front of Fireplace, Reading Book - Photographic Print

Men Reading in Front of the Friday Mosque or Masjet-Ejam, Herat, Afghanistan


Men Reading in Front of the Friday Mosque or Masjet-Ejam, Herat, Afghanistan


$19.99


Jane Sweeney Men Reading in Front of the Friday Mosque or Masjet-Ejam, Herat, Afghanistan - Photographic Print

Reading Headline Roosevelt Dead in Times Herald Newspaper in Front of the White House


Reading Headline Roosevelt Dead in Times Herald Newspaper in Front of the White House


$99.99


Thomas D. Mcavoy Reading Headline "Roosevelt Dead" in Times Herald Newspaper in Front of the White House - Premium Photographic Print

Middle Aged Man Smiling, Reading Mail By Mailbox, Outside Front of House


Middle Aged Man Smiling, Reading Mail By Mailbox, Outside Front of House


$24.99


H. Armstrong Roberts Middle Aged Man Smiling, Reading Mail By Mailbox, Outside Front of House - Photographic Print

Man Wearing, Dressing Gown Reading Magazine in Front of Fireplace


Man Wearing, Dressing Gown Reading Magazine in Front of Fireplace


$24.99


George Marks Man Wearing, Dressing Gown Reading Magazine in Front of Fireplace - Photographic Print

Elderly Man, Smiling, Sitting on Front Porch Step, Reading Letter


Elderly Man, Smiling, Sitting on Front Porch Step, Reading Letter


$24.99


H. Armstrong Roberts Elderly Man, Smiling, Sitting on Front Porch Step, Reading Letter - Photographic Print

Pregnant Teenager Reading in Front of Class, April 2, 1971


Pregnant Teenager Reading in Front of Class, April 2, 1971


$79.99


Ralph Crane Pregnant Teenager Reading in Front of Class, April 2, 1971 - Premium Photographic Print

Front Cover Illustration Showing a Lady Relaxing in a Hammock Reading a Book


Front Cover Illustration Showing a Lady Relaxing in a Hammock Reading a Book


$39.99


Front Cover Illustration Showing a Lady Relaxing in a Hammock Reading a Book - Giclee Print

A Boy Pupil Reading with His Teacher, at Her Desk in Front of the Blackboard


A Boy Pupil Reading with His Teacher, at Her Desk in Front of the Blackboard


$19.99


Henry Grant A Boy Pupil Reading with His Teacher, at Her Desk in Front of the Blackboard - Photographic Print

Getting The Main Idea Reading For


Getting The Main Idea Reading For


$17.33


These all-time favorite kits focus on one specific skill at a time. Every kit contains 10 cards for each reading level 2-6. Each card has a reading paragraph on the front and questions on the back. Answer cards make the activities self-directing and self-correcting.

Reading Comprehension Series 9-Set


Reading Comprehension Series 9-Set


$96.97


These all-time favorite kits focus on one specific skill at a time. Every kit contains 10 cards for each reading level 2-6. Each card has a reading paragraph on the front and questions on the back. Answer cards make the activities self-directing and self-correcting.

Canopy for Reading Center


Canopy for Reading Center


$125.2


The perfect accessory for the Sit and Store Reading Center with its brightly colored cotton canvas with scalloped front. It includes acrylic-framed side-window cutouts. Color/Finish: Red

Candlewood Suites Reading


Candlewood Suites Reading


$116


Candlewood Suites Reading is located in Reading, close to Reading Public Museum, VF Outlet Center, and Sovereign Center. Nearby points of interest also include Berkshire Mall and FirstEnergy Stadium. Hotel Features. Recreational amenities include a fitness facility. High speed Internet access is available in public areas. Additional property amenities include a safe deposit box at the front desk. Guestrooms. All guestrooms at Candlewood Suites Reading feature CD players and coffee/tea makers. Refrigerators and microwaves are offered. Televisions have cable channels and DVD players.

Reading 1 Teachers Edition


Reading 1 Teachers Edition


$56


"Invite children into the joy and benefit of reading. Pervasively Christian content reflects biblical truths and fosters Christian growth. Appealing art matches the tone of each story. A Variety of genres broaden taste. Begin building comprehension skills at the earliest levels. Predicting always precedes reading. Questioning strategies include all levels of developmental thinking. Provide appealing practice of first-grade skills. The sequence of skills matches the skill order in Phonics and English 1. Vocabulary teaching promotes long-range result Build silent and oral reading habits that further fluency. Instruction focuses on the life skill of reading silently for understanding and pleasure. Emphasis is placed on the life skill of reading orally to communicate the author's message. Encourage parent participation in the learning process. A letter to parents is available in the Reading 1 Worktext. Helpful tips for parents are available in the Reading 1 Teacher's Edition. A chart for assigning Reader stories to be shared at home is included at the front of each Student Reader. Enjoyable follow-up pages are provided for some selections in the Student Reader. Meet the needs of individual students. Lesson format can be adapted to different reading levels of students, group sizes, and time allotments. Question-answer format promotes interactive teaching. Worktext pages provide enjoyable activities for the review and application of comprehension skills. Options are provided for verbal and written student evaluation."

Reading the Will


Reading the Will


$34.99


Erdmann Reading the Will - Giclee Print

Effective Screen Reading


Effective Screen Reading


$24.95


Did you know reading text on a computer screen can be as much as 30 percent slower with less comprehension than reading printed text? Reading electronic text, e-mails and Web pages on a computer screen is different. That’s why this book is important no matter what industry you are in. Effective Screen Reading provides tried-and-tested principles for increasing your on-screen productivity and effectiveness. The easy-to-handle and quick-reference guide is the first book to address fast and effective reading and learning via the computer screen. Learn various techniques for better using your vision skills. Find out why sitting correctly in front of the screen is critical. Discover how to improve concentration and understanding of what you read. Examine e-mail folder structure and filing principles. Each chapter includes a preview of the goals of the chapter and topics to be covered and a summary of the highlights.

Hot Dots Reading Comprehension Kits


Hot Dots Reading Comprehension Kits


$19.4


Reading Comprehension Kits Hot Dots-Powered Reading Fun! These all-new Hot Dots Reading Comprehension Kits help students practice comprehension skills with Hot Dot-powered excitement. Each 50-story set contains 10 reading selections for each reading level from Grades 2 to 6. After reading the story on the front of the card the student flips it over to tackle four multiple-choice questions designed to test specific reading comprehension skills. The student can touch his answer choice with a Hot Dots Power Pen for immediate feedback or can write down his A B C D answer choices and check them against the included answer key. Stories include many genres aligned to reading standards. These fascinating Hot Dot-powered story cards are the perfect tool to challenge young students and hone reading comprehension skills. Grades 2+

Leave a Reply

 

wordpress stats